Abstract
Bioassays are routinely employed for sediment quality assessment. In order to be able to effectively use Bioassays responses in regulatory and management frameworks, toxicity scores, which rank toxicity data in defined classes that are continuous and difficult to interpret, should be reliable and suitable tools to support decisions about the presence or absence of toxicity in tested samples and on how toxic a sample is. A statistical approach is needed to define thresholds for toxicity scores. The Minimum Significance Difference (MSD) criterion allowed the evaluation of toxicity thresholds for each test-matrix and organism pair, based on large sets of experimental data. The MSD values were normalized with respect to the control, ranked in ascending order, and the 90th percentile was identified; the Toxicity Threshold (TT) was calculated by subtracting the 90th percentile from 100 and the Toxicity Limit (TL) was estimated as the percentage of control response multiplied by TT. Taking into account sample responses normalized with respect to control (S), when S > TL, the sample is considered nontoxic; when S ≤ TL, toxicity is statistically present. The MSD criterion was applied on a dataset of results from both published and ongoing projects using the validated embryotoxicity tests with the echinoid Paracentrotus lividus, the oyster Crassostrea gigas, and the mussel Mytilus galloprovincialis, on elutriates from sediments of the Venice Lagoon. Once the threshold defining presence or absence of toxicity had been calculated, four other toxicity classes were developed: low (for toxicity data expressed as percentage of effect), medium, high, and very high toxicity (for toxicity data expressed as TU50).
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Arizzi Novelli A, Argese E, Tagliapietra D, Bettiol C, Volpi Ghirardini A (2002) Toxicity of tributyltin and triphenyltin toward early life stages of Paracentrotus lividus (Echinodermata: Echinoidea). Environ Toxicol Chem 21:859–864
ASTM American Society for Testing and Materials (2004) Standard guide for conducting static acute toxicity tests starting with embryos of four species of saltwater bivalve molluscs E 724-98, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, 21pp
Critto A, Marcomini A (2001) Rischio ecologico e inquinamento chimico lagunare Cafoscarina Ed, Venice, Italy, p 162
His E, Seaman RNL, Beiras R (1997) A simplified bivalve larval bioassay method for seawater quality assessment. Water Res 31:351–355
His E, Beiras R, Seaman M (1999) The assessment of aquatic contamination: bioassays with bivalve larvae. Adv Marine Biol 37:1–178
Hunt JW, Anderson BS, Phillips BM, Newman J, Tjeederma RS, Fairey R, Puckett HM, Stephenson M, Smith RW, Wilson CJ, Taberski KM (2001) Evaluation and use of sediment toxicity reference sites for statistical comparisons in regional assessment. Environ Toxicol Chem 20:1266–1275
ICES (1997) Report of the ICES Advisory Committee on the Marine Environment (1997) ICES Cooperative Research Report no. 222, Copenhagen, pp 12–20
Losso C, Arizzi Novelli A, Picone M, Marchetto D, Pessa G, Molinaroli E, Ghetti PF, Volpi Ghirardini A (2004a) Evaluation of sediment resuspension effects on toxicity: preliminary results from the Lagoon of Venice. J Marine Systems 51:281–292
Losso C, His E, Ghetti PF, Volpi Ghirardini A (2004b) Sensitivity of embryotoxicity test with Mytilus galloprovincialis (LMK) towards some compounds of environmental interest (copper and pesticides). Environ Technol 25:841–846
Losso C, Arizzi Novelli A, Picone M, Marchetto D, Pantani C, Ghetti PF, Volpi Ghirardini A (2007) Potential role of sulfide and ammonia as confounding factors in elutriate toxicity bioassays with early life stages of sea urchins and bivalves. Ecotoxicol Environ Safety 66:252–253
Nendza M (2002) Inventory of marine biotest methods for the evaluation of dredged material and sediments. Chemosphere 48:865–883
Phillips B, Hunt JW, Anderson BS, Puckett HM, Fairey R, Wilson CJ, Tjeerdema R (2001) Statistical significance of sediment toxicity test results: threshold values derived by the detectable significance approach. Environ Toxicol Chem 20:371–373
Ravera O (2000) The lagoon of Venice: the result of both natural and human influence. J Limnol 59:19–30
Reynoldson TB, Thompson SP, Milani D (2002) Integrating multiple toxicological endpoints in a decision-making framework for contaminated sediments. Hum Ecol Risk Assess 8:1569–1584
Sfriso A, Facca C, Marcomini A (2005) Sedimentation rates and erosion processes in the lagoon of Venice. Environ Int 31:983–992
Stronkhorst J, Schipper C, Brils J, Dubbeldam M, Postma J, Van de Hoeven N (2003) Using marine bioassays to classify the toxicity of Dutch harbour sediments. Environ Toxicol Chem 22:1535–1547
Thursby GB, Heltshie J, Scott KJ (1997) Revised approach to test acceptability criteria using a statistical performance assessment. Environ Toxicol Chem 16:1322–1329
Venice Water Authority (1999) ‘‘Mappatura dell’inquinamento dei fondali lagunari’’ Project (1998–1999), Ministry of Public Works–Venice Water Authority, Consorzio Venezia Nuova, Final Report. Venice, Italy
Volpi Ghirardini A, Arizzi Novelli A, Losso C, Ghetti PF (2005a) Sperm cell and embryo toxicity tests using the sea urchin Paracentrotus lividus (LmK) Ostrander. In: Techniques in aquatic toxicology, volume 2. CRC Ed, pp 147–168
Volpi Ghirardini A, Losso C, Arizzi Novelli A, Baù A, His E, Ghetti PF (2005b) Mytilus galloprovincialis as bioindicator in embryotoxicity testing to evaluate sediment quality in the Lagoon of Venice (Italy). Chemistry Ecol 21:455–463
Volpi Ghirardini A, Arizzi Novelli A (2001) A sperm cell toxicity test procedure for the Mediterranean species Paracentrotus lividus (Echinodermata: Echinoidea). Environ Technol 22:439–445
Volpi Ghirardini A, Arizzi Novelli A, Tagliapietra D (2005d) Sediment toxicity assessment in the Lagoon of Venice (Italy) using Paracentrotus lividus (Echinodermata: Echinoidea) fertilization and embryo bioassays. Environ Int 31:1065–1077
Volpi Ghirardini A, Arizzi Novelli A, Losso C, Ghetti PF (2003) Sea urchin toxicity bioassays for sediment quality assessment in the Lagoon of Venice (Italy). Chemistry Ecol 19:99–111
Acknowledgment
This work supported in part by a grant from the Consorzio Ricerche Laguna (Co.Ri.La.) of Venice (Italy) and by ICSEL project (Integrazione delle Conoscenze Sull’Ecosistema Lagunare) promoted by Venice Water Authority through its concessionaire Consorzio Venezia Nuova and by Thetis S.p.A. Alison Garside revised the English text.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Losso, C., Picone, M., Novelli, A.A. et al. Developing Toxicity Scores for Embryotoxicity Tests on Elutriates with the Sea Urchin Paracentrotus lividus, the Oyster Crassostrea gigas, and the Mussel Mytilus galloprovincialis . Arch Environ Contam Toxicol 53, 220–226 (2007). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00244-006-0136-x
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00244-006-0136-x