A carbon tax to reduce CO2 emissions in Europe

doi:10.1016/0140-9883(92)90034-B

Energy Economics

Volume 14, Issue 4, October 1992, Pages 279-290

https://doi.org/10.1016/0140-9883(92)90034-B Get rights and content

Abstract

This paper examines the effects of introducing a tax on carbon dioxide emissions produced by combustion processes in OECD-European countries. A sectoral model of energy consumption is constructed to examine energy-saving and inter-fuel substitution effects induced by the introduction of various carbon taxes. The simulation period is 1989–1994. Our results provide a mild support to the environmental role of a carbon tax. Energy-saving or inter-fuel substitution processes, that result from the introduction of environmental taxation, stabilize emissions at the 1988 level only in the electricity generation sector, and only if high tax rates are assumed ($100/ton.C). By contrast, total emissions (all sectors and all fuels) keep growing, and the implementation of a tax of $100/ton.C can only reduce the emission growth rate. These results would recommend the introduction of several coordinated environmental instruments. The last part of the paper compares results concerning OECD-Europe with those obtained when examining a single country (Italy). The comparison does not seem to be in favour of a uniform carbon tax; it rather indicates that environmental policy should be designed taking into account the specific economic situation and technological choices of each single country. Country-specific coordinated environmental policies are to be recommended, where international coordination ought to concern environmental targets rather than instruments.

References (29)

M. Hoel
Global environmental problems: the effects of unilateral actions taken by one country
Journal of Environmental Economics and Management
(1991)
P. Agostini et al.
Fiscal policy to reduce air pollution in Italy
Ricerche Economiche
(1991)
A. Amano
Energy prices and CO₂ emissions in the 1990s'
Journal of Policy Modeling
(1991)
M. Botteon et al.
Is the European carbon tax really effective?
C. Carraro et al.
Strategies for the International Protection of Environment
C. Carraro et al.
Environmental Policy and the Choice of Production Technology
C. Carraro et al.
Taxation and the Environmental Innovation
A.W. Gregory et al.
Calibration as estimation
Econometric Reviews
(1990)
J.M. Griffin
Inter-fuel substitution possibilities: a translog application to intercountry data
International Economic Review
(1977)

J.M. Griffin and P.R. Gregory, ‘An intercountry trasnlog model of energy substitution responses’, American Economics...

P. Hoeller et al.

A survey of studies of the costs of reducing greenhouse gas emissions

OECD Economics and Statistics Department Working Paper

(December 1990)

P. Johnson et al.

The distributional consequences of environmental taxes

IFS Commentary

(July 1990)

B.-S. Lee et al.

Simulation estimation of time-series models

Journal of Econometrics

(1991)

Cited by (57)

The role of financial and trade globalization in enhancing environmental sustainability: Evaluating the effectiveness of carbon taxation and renewable energy in EU member countries
2024, Borsa Istanbul Review
The study addresses the pressing issue of environmental degradation, pinpointing carbon dioxide (CO₂) emissions as its primary driver, posing a threat to global environmental sustainability, including the member countries of the European Union (EU). Global warming problems persist, but previous studies have not adequately explored the factors that contribute to a reduction in carbon emissions in EU countries. The paper fills the gap by assessing the efficacy of carbon tax and eco-innovation in mitigating CO₂ levels from 1994 to 2019, considering the influence of renewable energy and various aspects of globalization. The study establishes long-term associations among the indicators examined using advanced methodologies, including the cross-sectional autoregressive distributed lag approach and the Westerlund cointegration method. Notably, the results highlight that carbon taxes, eco-innovation, renewable energy, and globalization contribute to slowing environmental deterioration, and economic progress plays a role in mitigating environmental sustainability challenges in EU member states. These findings reinforce the importance of robust strategies for reducing CO₂ emissions and minimizing adverse environmental impacts.
Impact of environmental fiscal reforms on carbon emissions of EURO-4 countries: CS-NARDL approach
2024, International Journal of Thermofluids
This study investigates the effects of the Environmental Fiscal Reforms (EFR) policy on carbon emissions of the top 4 economies of Europe, using annual time series data from 1995 to 2022. The study used a cross-sectional nonlinear autoregressive distributed lag (CS-NARDL) model to examine the relationship. Estimates claim that the variables have an asymmetric long-term and short-term relationship. The negative impacts of carbon taxes on carbon emissions prove that emissions are reduced when polluting activities are taxed. Fiscal policy instrument such as taxation changes the behaviour of the private sector by disincentivizing polluting activities. On the other hand, government expenditure on environmental protection encourages the private sector to embrace and invest in green technologies, decreasing carbon emissions. The ECM term is negative and statistically significant at a 1 percent significance level for CS-NARDL model, implying a stable long-run relationship between variables. It demonstrates that short-run disequilibrium converges to long-run equilibrium at a speed of 47.2 percent. The study also propels new insight into the effectiveness of EFR policy, showing that taxes act as a counter-incentive and expenditure as a positive policy intervention for reducing carbon emissions. EURO-4 countries set an example for policymakers worldwide by rebalancing their energy mix and expanding the use of cleaner alternative energy sources.
Carbon tax: Catalyst or hindrance for renewable energy use in climate change mitigation?
2024, Energy Strategy Reviews
This paper contributes to mitigating the debate on whether carbon taxes have positive or negative effects on climate change by presenting an investigation on the relationship between carbon taxes and renewable energy consumption. Taking advantage of the panel CS-ARDL model, we distinctly inspect the dynamics of the CO2 tax–renewable energy consumption nexus in both short and long runs, based on a dataset of 39 economies covering 1991–2019. Our findings suggest that in the short run, a CO2 tax initially impedes renewable energy consumption but promotes it in the long run, with more significant effects observed in advanced economies. Additionally, the marginal effect of a CO2 tax on renewable energy consumption is not influenced by its initial level or change direction. In accordance with our findings, we provide several implications for decision-makers.
Does the implementation of a Pigouvian tax be considered an effective approach to address climate change mitigation?
2023, Economic Analysis and Policy
This paper investigates the viability of environmental taxes as a means to mitigate greenhouse gas emissions within the European Union (EU) using the panel threshold model on two balanced panel data comprising countries from the European Union: the Northern and Western countries and Southern and Eastern countries for the period 2000–2020. The study's empirical results support the Pigouvian theory for developed countries, as they indicate an optimal minimum threshold for environmental taxes, where these taxes effectively contribute to reducing greenhouse gas emissions. However, the results diverge for emerging countries, revealing a maximum threshold for environmental taxes beyond which their impact in curbing emissions diminishes. To achieve the ambitious goal of climate neutrality, policymakers must adopt a comprehensive and diversified approach. This includes a combination of environmental taxes, more stringent regulations, and emission standards for industries. Additionally, the implementation of carbon pricing mechanisms, promotion of investments in sustainable fuels and technologies, and the establishment of low-carbon emission infrastructure are essential components of this strategy. By integrating these various measures, policymakers can better navigate the path toward climate neutrality and effectively combat climate change in the EU and beyond.
Emission taxation and sustainability in the mineral resources industry
2023, Resources Policy
The main objective of this research is to analyze the relationship between emission taxes and mineral resource efficiency in 32 Chinese administrative regions from 2000 to 2021. This analysis is conducted using the panel co-integration estimator, specifically the continuously updated full modified approach. The empirical estimations indicate that mineral resource efficiency is positively influenced by emission taxation policies, green finance initiatives, and improvements in industrial green technology indexes. However, carbon dioxide emissions and waste generation are identified as two significant challenges hindering the enhancement of mineral resource efficiency in Chinese administrative regions. Furthermore, mineral resource efficiency appears to be more responsive to green monetary policies, such as sustainable finance, compared to green fiscal policies like emission taxes. To enhance mineral resource efficiency, China could prioritize the improvement of the national emissions trading scheme (ETS) system, the development of sustainable power generation plants, and the establishment of a digital green financial market based on cryptocurrencies.
Green taxation and renewable energy technologies adoption: A global evidence
2023, Renewable Energy Focus
There is substantial literature on the determinants of renewable energy consumption. This growing interest is related to the fact that renewable energy is not only one of the main drivers of greenhouse gas mitigation but also its contribution to the achievement of other sustainable goals. Despite this strategic role, the adoption level of renewable energy remains quite low. In this article, we address one of the determinants so far ignored by the literature, namely the environmental tax. This study, therefore, examines the effect of environmental taxes on the adoption of renewable technologies for 49 global samples between the 1996-2017 periods. The results through the FE Driscoll and Kraay, the Newey-West, the system GMM, and the quantile regression methodologies show that environmental tax increase the consumption of renewable energy. However, taking into account disparities in the level of development, the results suggest that the environmental tax spurs renewable energy technologies adoption in developed countries while it decreases renewable energy technologies adoption in developing countries. As policy implications, policymakers within this sample should consider the optimization of environmental taxation as a policy toward environmental protection. This would cause energy consumers to opt for renewable energy sources of energy to escape these taxes.

View all citing articles on Scopus

View full text

A carbon tax to reduce CO2 emissions in Europe

Abstract

Journal of Environmental Economics and Management

Fiscal policy to reduce air pollution in Italy

Ricerche Economiche

Energy prices and CO2 emissions in the 1990s'

Journal of Policy Modeling

Is the European carbon tax really effective?

Strategies for the International Protection of Environment

Environmental Policy and the Choice of Production Technology

Taxation and the Environmental Innovation

Calibration as estimation

Econometric Reviews

Inter-fuel substitution possibilities: a translog application to intercountry data

International Economic Review