Abstract
This paper addresses the question of continuity in the long-term development of the Japanese tax system, focussing on fiscal reform in the 1930s in order to assess the impact of war on policy making. Specifically, it tracks the response of bureaucrats in the Finance Ministry to the challenge of how to reconcile economic growth with tax increases and redistribution of the burden. The views of ministerial officials are investigated on the basis of classified documents issued by the Tax Bureau, which previous research has only partially examined. The analysis points out that, rather than looking at war as an opportunity to push through a structural reform, bureaucrats continued to follow policy guidelines that were rooted in the developmentalist strategy established in the Meiji period. This conclusion helps to explain the resurgence of some key prewar features of taxation in the contemporary system, despite wartime reorganisation and attempts at further reform during the American occupation.
Bibliography
Archive documents
Hamada Norimi shiryō浜田徳海資料. Resources and Historical Collection Office of the Library of Economics, University of Tokyo.Search in Google Scholar
Shōwa zaiseishi shiryō昭和財政史資料. National Archives. http://www.digital.archives.go.jpSearch in Google Scholar
Published works (note: the place of publication for all works in Japanese is Tokyo)
AbeIsamu阿部勇 (1936): “Zeisei seirian eno hihan税制整理案への批判”. Ekonomisutoエコノミスト14.35 (11 Oct.): 24–27.Search in Google Scholar
And ōHaruo安藤春夫 (1937): “Uriagezei no hihan売上税の批判”. Ekonomisutoエコノミスト15.3 (21 Jan.): 11–15.Search in Google Scholar
Brownlee, W. Elliot/Ide, Eisaku/Fukagai, Yasunori (eds) (2013): The Political Economy of Transnational Tax Reform: The Shoup Mission to Japan in Historical Context. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.10.1017/CBO9781139519427Search in Google Scholar
Ekonomisutoエコノミスト (1936a): “Baba zōzei keikaku no rinkaku馬場増税計画の輪郭”. 14.22 (1 Aug.): 24–27.Search in Google Scholar
Ekonomisutoエコノミスト (1936b): “Zaisei–kokubō kokusaku. 1. Chūō chihō ikkan no zeisei kaikaku財政·国防国策 一、中央地方一貫の税制改革”. 14.28 (1 Oct.): 21–25.Search in Google Scholar
Ekonomisutoエコノミスト (1936c): “Junsen taisei toshite no zeisei kaikaku準戦体制としての税制改革”. 14.30 (21 Oct.): 22–24.Search in Google Scholar
Ekonomisutoエコノミスト (1936d): “Sangyōkai ni oyobosu shoeikyō 産業界に及ぼす諸影響”. 14.30: 27–30.Search in Google Scholar
Ekonomisutoエコノミスト (1936e): “Zeisei kaikaku o kaikyū betsu ni miru税制改革を階級別に見る”. 14.30: 30–35.Search in Google Scholar
Ekonomisutoエコノミスト (1936f): “Zōzei hayawakari増税早判り(1–4)”. 14.31 (1 Nov): 33–36; 14:32 (11 Nov.): 35–37; 14.33 (21 Nov.): 32–34; 14.34 (1 Dec): 46–48.Search in Google Scholar
Ekonomisutoエコノミスト (1937a): “Shin naikaku to keizai jissei新内閣と経済実勢”. 15.5 (11 Feb.): 11–12.Search in Google Scholar
Ekonomisutoエコノミスト (1937b): “Zaisei keizai seisaku no shin hōkō 財政経済政策の新方向”. 15.5 (11 Feb.): 12–13.Search in Google Scholar
Ekonomisutoエコノミスト (1937c): “Hayashi naikaku no shunō 林内閣の首脳”. 15.5 (11 Feb.): 29–31.Search in Google Scholar
Ekonomisutoエコノミスト (1937d): “Yūki zeisei hayawakari 結城税制早判り” (1–5). 15.7 (1 March): 27–30 to 15.11 (11 Apr.): 32–35.Search in Google Scholar
Ekonomisutoエコノミスト (1937e): “Konoe naikaku no seiritsu igi近衛内閣の成立意義”. 15.17 (11 June): 8.Search in Google Scholar
Ekonomisutoエコノミスト (1937f): “Zaikei seisaku no hōkō ikan. Babaizumu wa dō naru ka財経政策の方向如何―馬場イズムはどうなるか”. 15.17: 11–12.Search in Google Scholar
Ekonomisutoエコノミスト (1937g): “Seihen to kakushijō 政変と各市場”. 15.17 (11 June): 12–14.Search in Google Scholar
Ekonomisutoエコノミスト (1937h): “TaiShi sensen shinkyokumen ni hairu対支戦線新局面に入る”. 15.36 (21 Dec.): 6.Search in Google Scholar
HashimotoTōru橋本徹 (1959): “Zeisei kaikaku no dōkō. Shōwa 15 nen kaikaku to sono tenkai税制改革の動向―昭和十五年改革とその展開”. Keizaigaku ronkyū経済学論究13.2: 57–96.Search in Google Scholar
HirataKeiichirō 平田敬一郎/ChūSaichi忠佐市/IzumiMinomatsu泉美之松 (eds) (1979): Shōwa zeisei no kaiko to tenbō昭和税制の回顧と展望, 2 vols. Ōkura zaimu kyōkai.Search in Google Scholar
HorikiriZenbei堀切善兵衛 (1936): “Zōzei mondai ni tsuite増税問題に就いて”. Seiyū 政友432 (August): 8.Search in Google Scholar
IdeEisaku井手英策 (2006): “Gendaiteki sozei shisutemu no kōzō to sono zasetsu現代的租税システムの構造とその挫折”. Kaikei kensa kenkyū会計検査研究33: 259–278. Reprint (2012) as chapter 3 of Takahashi zaisei no kenkyū高橋財政の研究. Yūhikaku.Search in Google Scholar
IkegamiTakehiko池上岳彦 (1986): “Dai ichiji taisengo Nihon ni okeru zeisei seiri mondai no hassei第一次大戦後日本における税制整理問題の発生”. Keizaigaku 経済学48.4: 39–59.Search in Google Scholar
IkegamiTakehiko 池上岳彦 (1991). “Senkanki Nihon no zeisei seiri戦間期日本の税制整理”. Niigata daigaku shōgaku ronshū新潟大学商学論集23: 1–78.Search in Google Scholar
IkegamiTakehiko池上岳彦 (1993). “Senkanki ni okeru chokusetsuzei futan no chiikikan kakusa戦間期における直接税負担の地域間格差”. Niigata daigaku shōgaku ronshū新潟大学商学論集25: 1–52.Search in Google Scholar
JinnoNaohiko神野直彦 (1979a): “Baba zeisei kaikakuan馬場税制改革案” (Part 1, 2). Shōken keizai証券経済127: 130–156; 128: 108–137.Search in Google Scholar
JinnoNaohiko 神野直彦 (1979b): “Baba zeisei kaikakuan no keisei katei馬場税制改革案の形成過程”. Jurisutoジュリスト692: 107–118.Search in Google Scholar
JinnoNaohiko神野直彦 (1981): “1940 nen (Shōwa 15 nen) no zeisei kaikaku 1940年（昭和 15 年）の税制改革” (Part 1, 2). Shōken keizai証券経済135: 135–156, 136: 107–137.Search in Google Scholar
JinnoNaohiko 神野直彦 (1985): “Shakai seisakuteki sozei seisaku no tenkai社会政策的租税政策の展開”. Keizaigaku zasshi経済学雑誌86.3: 15–48.Search in Google Scholar
JinnoNaohiko神野直彦 (1987–88): “Kindai Nihon zeisei no keisei katei近代日本税制の形成過程 (Part 1, 2). Keizaigaku zasshi経済学雑誌88.2/3: 116–143, 5/6: 58–80.Search in Google Scholar
JinnoNaohiko神野直彦 (1999): “The ‘Japanese-Model’ Fiscal System”. In: The Japanese Economic System and its Historical Origins(208–238). Edited by Tetsuji Okazaki and Masahiro Okuno-Fujiwara. Oxford: Oxford University Press.Search in Google Scholar
JinnoNaohiko神野直彦 (2000): Tōkyō daigaku keizai gakubu shozō tokubetsu shiryō “Hamada Norimi shiryō” mokuroku東京大学経済学部所蔵特別資料『浜田徳海資料』目録. Tōkyō daigaku keizai gakubu toshokan.Search in Google Scholar
JinnoNaohiko神野直彦 (2009): “Sozei seisaku no keisei katei租税政策の形成過程”. Chapter 1 of Sozei no zaisei shakaigaku租税の財政社会学 (3–23). Edited by JinnoNaohiko神野直彦 and IkegamiTakehiko池上岳彦. Zeimu keiri kyōkai.Search in Google Scholar
KanazawaFumio 金澤史男 (1984): “Ryōzei ijōron tenkai katei no kenkyū 両税委譲論展開過程の研究”. Shakai kagaku kenkyū社会科学研究36.1: 67–145. Reprint (2010) as chapter 1 of Kindai Nihon chihō zaiseishi kenkyū近代日本地方財政史研究 (1–76). Nihon keizai hyōronsha.Search in Google Scholar
KatōKumeshirō 加藤久米四郎 (1936): “Zeisei kaikaku to chihō jichi 税制改革と地方自治”. Seiyū 政友435 (Nov.): 7–16.Search in Google Scholar
KuriharaKōda栗原広太 (1945): Baba Eiichi den馬場鍈一伝. Ko Baba Eiichi shi kinenkai.Search in Google Scholar
Martin, Isaac W./AjayMehrotra/MonicaPrasad (eds) (2009): The New Fiscal Sociology: Taxation in Comparative and Historical Perspective. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Search in Google Scholar
MiyamotoKen’ichi宮本憲一 (1961): “Gendai zeisei keisei katei no kenkyū 現代税制形成過程の研究”. Kanazawa daigaku hōbungakubu ronshū金沢大学法文学部論集8: 169–273.Search in Google Scholar
MiyamotoKen’ichi 宮本憲一 (1968): “Shōwa kyōkō to zaisei seisaku. Inoue zaisei to Takahashi zaisei昭和恐慌と財政政策―井上財政と高橋財政”. Chapter 3 of Kyōkō kara sensō e恐慌から戦争へ (Vol. 3 of Kōza Nihon shihonshugi hattatsu shiron講座日本資本主義発達史論), edited by KawaiIchirō川合一郎 et al. Nihon hyōronsha.Search in Google Scholar
MotoyamaShūji元山修二 (1936): “Zeisei kaikaku no kihon mondai税制改革の基本問題”. Zei 税14.6 (July): 1–4.Search in Google Scholar
MukaiYurio 迎由里男 (2000): “Ōkura kanryō to zeisei kaikaku大蔵官僚と税制改革”. Chapter 1 of Kindai Nihon no keizai kanryō近代日本の経済官僚 (1–42). Edited by NamikataShōichi波形昭一 and HorikoshiYoshiaki堀越芳昭. Nihon keizai hyōronsha.Search in Google Scholar
Naiseishikenkyūkai内政史研究会 (1971): Matsukuma Hideo shi danwa sokkiroku松隈秀雄氏談話速記録, 2 vols. Naiseishi kenkyūkai.Search in Google Scholar
OECD: Revenue Statistics tax to GDP ratio changes between 1965 and 2011. http://www.oecd.org/ctp/tax-policy/revenue-statistics-ratio-change-all-years.htm (1/09/2014)Search in Google Scholar
OgawaGōtarō小川郷太郎 (1933): “Keizaijō yori mite zōzei ga tekitō経済上より見て増税が適当”. Tōyō keizai shinpō東洋経済新報1555 (24 June): 57–58.Search in Google Scholar
ŌguchiKiroku大口喜六 (1933): “Zōzei ni yoru seifu no zōshū wa saigo no shudan増税による政府の増収は最後の手段”. Tōyō keizai shinpō東洋経済新報1555: 58–59.Search in Google Scholar
ŌguchiKiroku大口喜六 (1936a): “Zōzei ni taisuru ikkōsatsu増税に対する一考察”. Seiyū 政友429 (May): 8–13.Search in Google Scholar
ŌguchiKiroku大口喜六 (1936b). “Zaisanzei narabini kaokuzei to zeisei kaisei no yōtei財産税並に家屋税と税制改正の要諦”. Ekonomisutoエコノミスト14.19 (1 July): 18–20.Search in Google Scholar
ŌguchiKiroku大口喜六 (1936c). “Zeisei kaikakuan wo hyō su税制改革案を評す”. Seiyū 政友434 (Oct.): 4–11.Search in Google Scholar
ŌkurashōShōwa zaiseishi henshūshitsu大蔵省昭和財政史編集室 (ed.) (1954, 1957): Chihō zaisei地方財政; Sozei 租税. Vols 14 and 5 of Shōwa zaiseishi昭和財政史, 18 vols (1954–64). Tōyō keizai shinpōsha.Search in Google Scholar
Ōsaka Mainichi shinbun 大阪毎日新聞 (1934a): “Zen kakuryō kuchi wo soroete zōshō ni fuman hyōmei全閣僚口を揃へて蔵相に不満表明”. 6 November.Search in Google Scholar
Ōsaka Mainichi shinbun大阪毎日新聞 (1934b). “Zōshō: kenzen zaisei shugi no bōsen 蔵相・健全財政主義の防戦”. 18 November.Search in Google Scholar
Ōsaka Mainichi shinbun大阪毎日新聞 (1934c). “Matsuwaranu fukkatsu yōkyū no sesshō纏らぬ復活要求の折衝”. 19 November.Search in Google Scholar
Ōsaka Mainichi shinbun大阪毎日新聞 (1934d). “Rikukai ryōshō to zōshō ronsen, tagaini aiyurazu陸海両相と蔵相論戦、互に相譲らず”. 21 November, evening ed.Search in Google Scholar
Revelant, Andrea (2013): “Tax Reform as Social Policy: Adjusting to change in interwar Japan”. Modern Asian Studies47.3: 851–894.10.1017/S0026749X12000522Search in Google Scholar
Seiyū政友 (1936): “Zeisei seirian yōkō to yoron税制整理案要綱と世論”. 434 (Oct.): 12–21.Search in Google Scholar
Senzenki kanryōsei kenkyūkai戦前期官僚制研究会 (ed.)/HataIkuhiko秦郁彦 (1981): Senzenki Nihon kanryōsei no seido–soshiki–jinji戦前期日本官僚制の制度· 組織· 人事. Tōkyō daigaku shuppankai.Search in Google Scholar
Takayose Shōzō高寄昇三 (2010–11): Shōwa chihō zaiseishi昭和地方財政史, 2 vols. Kōjin no tomosha.Search in Google Scholar
Tōkyō Asahi shinbun東京朝日新聞 (1937a): “SeiMin ni iron aru mo zōzei dankō no hōshin政民に異論あるも増税断行の方針”. 3 November.Search in Google Scholar
Tōkyō Asahi shinbun東京朝日新聞 (1937b): “Zenpanteki zeisei kaisei miawase ni kessu全般的税制改正見合せに決す”. 6 November.Search in Google Scholar
Tōkyō Asahi shinbun東京朝日新聞 (1938): “Zōzeian no yōkō happyō増税案の要綱発表”. 30 January.Search in Google Scholar
Yamamoto Teijirō山本悌二郎 (1936): “Baba zōshō ni shissu馬場蔵相に質す”. Seiyū 政友434 (Oct.): 1–3.Search in Google Scholar
Note
The fieldwork for this paper was supported by Ca’ Foscari University of Venice. I am grateful to Mark Metzler, whose reflections on “policy regimes” helped me to frame tax issues in a long-term perspective.
©2015 by De Gruyter
