초록
The nature of thematic roles is a central, yet controversial, issue both for models of linguistic competence as well as for models of sentence processing. McRae et al (1997b) proposed to treat thematic roles as verb-specific prototypes that can be empirically described by resorting to a modified version of the traditional feature norm paradigm. In this paper, we present the results of two norming experiments in which we extended this approach to incorporate the distinction between filler-inherent and verb-entailed features, the latter being further characterized on the basis of their association with one or more phases of the time course of the event. In the first experiment, we asked to a group of speakers to list the prototypical characteristics of the fillers of two semantic roles, agent and patient, for a set of 20 Italian transitive verbs. We then manually annotated the collected features according to our classification of feature types. In the second experiment, we encouraged participants to list as many properties as possible to describe the verb roles with respect to three different time slots: before, during and after the event described by the verb takes place. The collected data supports the claim in McRae et al (1997b) that thematic roles can be also treated as verb-specific concepts. The first experiment reveals differences between the agent and the patient roles, which instead disappears in the second experiment. The methodological novelty introduced in the latter is also able to highlight the interaction between the speakers’ knowledge of verb roles and the temporal phases of the events.
키워드
thematic roles, verbs, semantic memory, feature norms
참고문헌(61)
-
[학술지] Altmann, G. / 1999 / Incremental interpretation at verbs: restricting the domain of subsequent reference / Cognition 73 : 247 ~ 264
-
[학술지] Altmann, G. / 2007 / The real-time mediation of visual attention by language and world knowledge: linking anticipatory (and other) eye movements to linguistic processing / Journal of Memory and Language 57 : 502 ~ 518
-
[학술지] Andrews, M. / 2009 / Integrating experiential and distributional data to learn semantic representations / Psychological Review 116 (3) : 463 ~ 498
-
[학술지] Artstein, R. / 2008 / Inter-Coder Agreement for Computational Linguistics / Computational Linguistics 34 (4) : 555 ~ 596
-
[학술지] Ashcraft, M. / 1978 / Property norms for typical and atypical items from 17categories: A description and discussion / Memory & Cognition 6 : 227 ~ 232
-
[학술대회] Baker, C. F. / 1998 / The Berkeley FrameNet Project / Proceedings of COLING-ACL ’98 : 86 ~ 90
-
[학술대회] Barbu, E. / 2008 / A Comparison of Feature Norms and WordNet / Proceedings of the 4th Global Wordnet Conference (GWC 2008) : 56 ~ 73
-
[학술대회] Baroni, M. / 2008 / Bridging the gap between semantic theory and computational simulations / Proceedings of the ESSLLI 2008 Workshop on Distributional Semantics
-
[학술지] Baroni, M. / 2010 / Strudel: a corpus-based semantic model based on properties and types / Cognitive Science 34 (2) : 222 ~ 254
-
[학술지] Bicknell, K. / 2010 / Effects of event knowledge in processing verbal arguments / Journal of Memory and Language 63 (4) : 489 ~ 505
-
[학술지] Cohen, J. / 1960 / A coefficient of agreement for nominal scales / Educational and Psychological Measurement 20 : 37 ~ 46
-
[학술지] Collins, A. / 1975 / A spreading-activation theory of semantic processing / Psychological review 82 : 407 ~ 428
-
[학술지] Cree, G. / 2003 / Analyzing the factors underlying the structure and computation of the meaning of chipmunk, cherry, chisel, cheese, and cello (and many other such concrete nouns) / Journal of Experimental Psychology : General 132 : 163 ~ 201
-
[학술지] Cree, G. S. / 1999 / An attractor model of lexical conceptual processing: Simulating semantic priming / Cognitive Science : A Multidisciplinary Journal 23 (3) : 371 ~ 414
-
[학술지] De Deyne, S. / 2008 / Exemplar by feature applicability matrices and other Dutch normative data for semantic concepts / Behavior Research Methods 40 (4) : 1030 ~ 1048
-
[학술지] Devereux, B. J. / 2014 / The Centre for Speech, Language and the Brain (CSLB) concept property orms / Behavior Research Methods 46 (5) : 1119 ~ 1127
-
[단행본] Dowty, D. / 1989 / Properties, Types, and Meanings, vol. II / Kluwer : 69 ~ 130
-
[학술지] Dowty, D. / 1991 / Thematic Proto-Roles and Argument Selection / Language 67 (3) : 547 ~ 619
-
[학술지] Ferretti, T. R. / 2007 / Verb aspect and the activation of event knowledge / Journal of Experimental Psychology : Learning, Memory, and Cognition 33 : 182 ~ 196
-
[학술지] Ferretti, T. R. / 2001 / Integrating Verbs, Situation Schemas, and Thematic Role Concepts / Journal of Memory and Language 44 (4) : 516 ~ 547
-
[단행본] Fillmore, C. J. / 1968 / Universals in Linguistic Theory / Holt, Rinehart, and Winston : 1 ~ 88
-
[학술대회] Frassinelli, D. / 2012 / Concepts in context: Evidence from a feature norming study / Proceedings of the Annual Meeting of the Cognitive Science Society (CogSci 2012) : 1566 ~ 1571
-
[학술지] Garrard, P. / 2001 / Prototypicality, distinctiveness, and intercorrelation: Analyses of the semantic attributes of living and nonliving concepts / Cognitive Neuropsychology 18 (2) : 125 ~ 174
-
[학술지] Garrard, P. / 2001 / Prototypicality, distinctiveness, and intercorrelation: Analyses of the semantic attributes of living and nonliving concepts / Cognitive Neuropsychology 18 (2) : 125 ~ 174
-
[학술지] Gildea D. / 2002 / Automatic labeling of semantic roles / Computational Linguistics 28 (3) : 245 ~ 288
-
[학술지] Hampton, J. A. / 1979 / Polymorphous concepts in semantic memory / Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior 18 (4) : 441 ~ 461
-
[학술지] Hare, M. / 2009 / Activating event knowledge / Cognition 111 (2) : 151 ~ 167
-
[학술지] Hinton, G. / 1991 / Lesioning an attractor network: Investigations of acquired dyslexia / Psychological review 98 : 74 ~ 95
-
[학술지] Kamide, Y. / 2003 / The time-course of prediction in incremental sentence processing: Evidence from anticipatory eye movements / Journal of Memory and Language 49 : 133 ~ 156
-
[학술지] Kelly, C. / 2013 / Automatic Extraction of Property Norm-Like Data From Large Text Corpora / Cognitive Science 38 (4) : 638 ~ 682
-
[학위논문] Kipper-Schuler, K. / 2005 / Verbnet: A Broad-Coverage, Comprehensive Verb Lexicon
-
[학술대회] Kremer, G. / 2010 / Predicting Cognitively Salient Modifiers of the Constitutive Parts of Concepts / Proceedings of the 2010 Workshop on Cognitive Modeling and Computational Linguistics : 54 ~ 62
-
[학술지] Kremer, G. / 2011 / A set of semantic norms for German and Italian / Behavior Research Methods 43 (1) : 97 ~ 109
-
[학위논문] Lebani, G. E. / 2012 / STaRS.sys: designing and building a commonsense-knowledge enriched wordnet for therapeutic purposes
-
[학술대회] Lebani, G. E. / 2010 / A Feature Type Classification for Therapeutic Purposes: a preliminary evaluation with non-expert speakers / Proceedings of the 4th Linguistic Annotation Workshop (LAW IV) : 157 ~ 161
-
[학술지] Lenci, A. / 2013 / BLIND: A set of semantic feature norms from the congenitally blind / Behavior Research Methods 45 (4) : 1218 ~ 1233
-
[단행본] Levin, B. / 2005 / Argument Realization / Cambridge University Press
-
[학술지] Matsuki K. / 2011 / Eventbased Plausibility Immediately Influences On-line Language Comprehension / Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 37 (4) : 913 ~ 934
-
[단행본] McRae, K. / 2002 / Category-specificity in mind and brain. East Sussex / Psychology Press
-
[학술지] McRae, K. / 2009 / People Use their Knowledge of Common Events to Understand Language, and Do So as Quickly as Possible / Language and Linguistics Compass 3 (6) : 1417 ~ 1429
-
[학술지] McRae, K. / 2005 / Semantic feature production norms for a large set of living and nonliving things / Behavior Research Methods 37 (4) : 547 ~ 559
-
[학술지] McRae, K. / 1997 / On the nature and scope of featural representations of word meaning / Journal of Experimental Psychology : General 126 : 99 ~ 130
-
[학술지] McRae, K. / 1997 / Thematic Roles as Verb-specific Concepts / Language and Cognitive Processes 12 (2/3) : 137 ~ 176
-
[학술지] McRae, K. / 2005 / A basis for generating expectancies for verbs from nouns / Memory & Cognition 33 (7) : 1174 ~ 1184
-
[학술지] McRae, K. / 1998 / Modeling the influence of thematic fit (and other constraints) in on-line sentence comprehension / Journal of Memory and Language 38 : 283 ~ 312
-
[학술지] Meyer, D. / 2006 / The strucplot framework: Visualizing multiway contingency tables with vcd / Journal of Statistical Software 17 (3)
-
[학술지] Montefinese, M. / 2013 / Semantic memory: A feature-based analysis and new norms for Italian / Behavior Research Methods 45 (2) : 440 ~ 461
-
[학술대회] Poesio, M. / 2008 / Supervised relation extraction for ontology learning from text based on a cognitively plausible model of relations / Proceedings of the 3rd Workshop on Ontology Learning and Population : 1 ~ 5
-
[학술대회] Roller, S. / 2014 / Feature Norms of German Noun Compounds / Proceedings of the 10th Workshop on Multiword Expressions (MWE 2014) : 104 ~ 108
-
[학술지] Rosch, E. / 1975 / Family resemblances: Studies in the internal structure of categories / Cognitive psychology 7 : 753 ~ 605
-
[학술지] Sartori, G. / 2004 / Semantic relevance and semantic disorders / Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience 16 (3) : 439 ~ 452
-
[학술지] Smith, E. E. / 1974 / Structure and process in semantic memory: A featural model for semantic decisions / Psychological Review 81 (3) : 214 ~ 241
-
[학술지] Steyvers, M. / 2011 / Combining Background Knowledge and Learned Topics / Topics in Cognitive Science 3 (1) : 18 ~ 47
-
[학술지] Storms, G. / 2010 / Acta psychologica special issue on formal modeling of semantic concepts 133 (3) : 213 ~ 304
-
[학술지] Traxler, M. J. / 2000 / Priming in sentence processing: intralexical spreading activation, schemas, and situation models / Journal of Psycholinguistic Research 29 : 581 ~ 595
-
[학술지] Van Valin, R. D., Jr / 1999 / Generalized Semantic Roles and the Syntax-Semantics Interface / Empirical Issues in Formal Syntax and Semantics 2 : 373 ~ 389
-
[학술지] Vigliocco, G. / 2004 / Representing the meanings of object and action words: The featural and unitary semantic space hypothesis / Cognitive Psychology 48 : 422 ~ 488
-
[학술지] Vigliocco, G. / 2006 / The role of semantics and grammatical class in the neural representation of words / Cerebral Cortex 16 : 1790 ~ 1976
-
[학술지] Vinson, D. P. / 2008 / Semantic feature production norms for a large set of objects and events / Behavior Research Methods 40 (1) : 183 ~ 190
-
[학술지] Vinson, D. / 2003 / The breakdown of semantic knowledge: Insights from a statistical model of meaning representation / Brain and Language 86 : 347 ~ 365
-
[학술지] Wu, L. / 2009 / Perceptual simulation in conceptual combination:evidence from property generation / Acta Psychologica 132 (2) : 173 ~ 189